The GCC deal – democracy for Yemen?

November 28, 2011 5:39 pm2 commentsViews:

In the royal surroundings of one of the many al-Saud palaces in Riyadh, President Saleh of Yemen signed the Gulf initiative last Wednesday, effectively signing away his presidency.

The Gulf initiative calls for Saleh to pass on his powers to his deputy, Abd-Rabbo Mansur Hadi, and then for Yemen to hold Presidential elections after an optimistic three-month period.

Decisively, the deal gives the President, and his family members, immunity from future prosecution, a move that has angered the youth movement that took to the streets of Yemen in February.

Although it is far too optimistic to say that this is the end of the political crisis that has plagued Yemen this year, there are some definite positives that have emerged out of this deal.

Firstly, after months of violence and an increase in fighting between rival military factions, the deal greatly reduces the chances of civil war in the poorest Arab state. Saleh’s sons and nephews control large parts of the Yemeni armed forces; the GCC deal brings the hope that they may be removed from their positions without a fight.

Secondly, the deal highlights the positive role the international community can play. Attempts to find a way out of the crisis have been very laborious, but gradually the US and the EU were able to get their act together and strong-arm Saleh into signing. It is very likely that the main reason he did sign was the asset freeze and travel ban hanging over his head. Saleh was never a Gaddafi, once he realised the international community was not bluffing he decided to sign the deal, preferring it to joining the ranks of Mugabe and Assad.

However, despite the probable immediate benefit of avoiding a disastrous civil war, there are several long-term problems that arise.

Many members of the youth movement, especially those who consider themselves ‘independent’, i.e. not affiliated to the official opposition parties, are completely against the GCC deal. This has been the case since the deal first emerged in April, and since then there has been a strong sentiment amongst these protesters that the JMP opposition grouping is effectively stealing the youth revolution. The independent youth have complained at times of being stifled by the JMP and by the defected First Armoured Division, and have even said that they are the reason why the revolution has taken so long.

The GCC deal may be particularly problematic in the future because of those associated with it, namely Saleh and the GCC itself. Saleh is a master of deception, and even now that he has signed, it is likely that he will try and find a way to lessen the effect of the deal. He may attempt to negotiate and ensure that his sons and other family members remain in their positions, effectively retaining the control of Saleh’s Sanhan sub-tribe. Saleh is back in Yemen, announcing a Presidential Pardon for offences committed during the political crisis, apart from the bomb attack against him. He seems to have forgotten that, officially, he has no powers. Preliminary reports concerning the make-up of the next cabinet say that the President’s son, Republican Guard head Ahmed Ali Saleh, is to be one of the Deputy Prime Minister’s, and the Minister of Interior; not a particularly encouraging sign.

The GCC itself is a group of six autocratic monarchies, not particularly inspiring for Yemenis wishing to leave the era of authoritarianism. The strongest power in the regional alliance is Saudi Arabia, a country known for its often negative interventions in Yemen over the past decades. Does Saudi Arabia really want a democratic Yemen that could potentially inspire those within Saudi itself? More importantly, will it allow a strong Yemen, independent of Saudi control?

Has there ever been an instance of a group of effectively absolute monarchies overseeing a democratic transition?

The GCC deal presents possibly the most realistic short term resolution to the Yemeni quagmire. It lessens the chance of civil war that would set Yemen back by decades. Nevertheless, it does not meet the demands of the vast majority of those who started the revolution, people who want the complete removal of an endemically corrupt regime. As events in Egypt currently show, those protesting in the Arab world do not seem likely to accept solutions that do not give them all of what they want. Revolution 2.0 may be on its way in Yemen. That is if Saleh does not manage to wriggle free, once again.

Abubakr Al-Shamahi

Views expressed in articles are the author’s and do not represent Comment Middle East

Tags:
  • Abdullatif

    Maybe Yemen should follow its destined path and be part of the GCC once and for all.

  • Joseph

    Abdullatif, I don’t think a stable GCC would want a very unstable Yemen to be part of it.